The Pepsi Contract That KFC Walked Away From and Taco Bell Renewed

Author: Eugene Chan
Published: 18 November 2026 on LinkedIn

  • A partnership that lasts forty years isn’t necessarily a strong one. It may just be a default nobody has challenged yet.

  • The Story

    On October 15, KFC announced it is replacing Pepsi with Coca-Cola across its roughly 3,700 U.S. restaurants, starting in January 2027 and reaching every location by spring. It ends a relationship of nearly 40 years that began when PepsiCo bought the chain in 1986. PepsiCo spun KFC off in 1997, but the drinks kept flowing through KFC’s parent company, Yum! Brands. Financial terms weren’t disclosed. Bank of America analysts estimated the loss could cost PepsiCo about $500 million in annual sales, as reported by Reuters, and CNBC reported it was the first time in decades that the chain has changed drink suppliers.

    KFC framed the move as part of an effort to evolve the brand and offer a more relevant experience, and its U.S. president said the partnership is about more than what’s in the cup. The chain has been testing iced coffees and shakes at its Open House test restaurant in McKinney, Texas, and has been losing diners to rivals such as Chick-fil-A and Popeyes. Coca-Cola pointed to its portfolio and its capacity to develop new beverages.

    A week later, on October 22, KFC’s sister chain Taco Bell went the other way. It announced it is keeping PepsiCo as its beverage partner through 2036. The companies said they will keep co-developing new drinks and foods, including new Doritos Locos Tacos flavors, and called the Baja Blast drink a $1 billion brand. Taco Bell is aiming for $5 billion in beverage revenue by 2030. A PepsiCo spokesperson told Reuters the Taco Bell agreement had been renewed recently, so the public announcement a week after the KFC news was a choice about timing.

    Taco Bell is the larger prize, with $17 billion in U.S. system-wide sales last year versus roughly $5 billion for KFC. PepsiCo can use the win: its North America beverage unit declined 2% last quarter, and its CEO said on the earnings call that the company is “not competing well in soft drinks.”

    Same parent, same supplier, one week apart, opposite decisions.

  • This Was Not an Isolated Case

    Fountain accounts are moving more than the “large chains rarely switch” cliché suggests. Coca-Cola has won Culver’s, Arby’s, and Panda Express from Pepsi in recent years and won back Marriott after 34 years, while Pepsi took Subway from Coke in 2024. KFC itself is a return trip: before 1986, most KFC restaurants poured Coke, and the chain was Coca-Cola’s second-biggest fountain customer, behind only McDonald’s.

    That history matters. KFC’s forty years with Pepsi started with an ownership decision, not a customer’s choice, and then continued through a spin-off that removed the original reason.

  • Why It Happened

    Start with what held the KFC relationship together.

    Default effect (status quo bias):

    People disproportionately stick with the existing option, even when alternatives are as good or better, because changing takes effort, carries regret risk, and makes the current option feel normal (Samuelson and Zeckhauser, 1988).

    KFC’s Pepsi relationship was created by ownership in 1986 and persisted by default after the 1997 spin-off. A default holds until a rival supplies a reason large enough to overcome the effort and risk of changing. By the companies’ own public statements, Coca-Cola’s pitch was about innovation capability and new food-and-drink combinations.

    Taco Bell’s relationship had a default too, but it also had something else.

    Asset specificity:

    An investment that is worth much more inside one relationship than outside it, which makes both parties dependent on each other and costly to leave (Williamson, 1985).

    Baja Blast and the Doritos Locos Tacos collaboration are worth more inside the Taco Bell and PepsiCo relationship than outside it. Leaving would mean forfeiting a brand the companies describe as a $1 billion business. Placer.ai’s research director described the Baja Blast lineup as a differentiator and said product exclusives can drive visits.

    Pledges:

    Costly, relationship-specific commitments one party makes to signal it will stay and to deepen the other’s commitment (Anderson and Weitz, 1992).

    Co-developed products and a 10-year term are pledges. Each makes it more expensive for either side to walk away, which is what makes the commitment credible.

    Tenure, in this reading, is just the age of a default. What makes a partner hard to leave is what you’ve built that wouldn’t survive the separation.

  • The Signal Nobody Priced In

    The timing of the Taco Bell announcement did work beyond the news. By saying the renewal had already been signed, PepsiCo told investors and other chains that its biggest restaurant relationship wasn’t up for grabs. It also showed what Coca-Cola can win and what it apparently couldn’t: the chicken chain with a default, not the Mexican-inspired chain with a co-created brand.

    The CEO’s candid admission carries its own signal. A supplier that says publicly it isn’t competing well is telling customers its default advantage is eroding. The Taco Bell renewal shows what PepsiCo has left when defaults stop working: products that exist only because of a specific partnership.

    For other chains, the lesson is about what a challenger needs to offer. Based on what’s public, Coca-Cola didn’t win KFC on tenure or visible loyalty. It offered a future.

  • Where This Actually Gets Fixed

    Any supplier, vendor, or partner can face this. The fix is to turn defaults into assets before a rival tests them.

    • Ask what exists inside the relationship that would be lost. If the honest answer is “mostly history,” the relationship is a default, and defaults expire when a rival supplies a reason.

    • Build pledges. Co-develop products, joint roadmaps, or exclusives the customer can’t get elsewhere. Exclusives give the customer a reason to stay that doesn’t depend on price.

    • Audit the reasons to stay every year. Long relationships are at the most risk, because inertia hides the risk until someone challenges it.

    • Show your innovation pipeline before the challenger does. The challenger’s pitch to KFC emphasized new drinks and co-development. Incumbents should lead with the same.

    • For buyers, separate the commodity from the strategic. A pouring-rights contract is a commodity. Menu innovation is a strategy. Taco Bell treats beverages as the second and bought accordingly.

    • Make commitment visible and costly. A 10-year term plus joint launches signals more than a renewal announcement alone.

  • Where This Breaks Down

    • KFC’s reasons aren’t public. Terms weren’t disclosed, and marketing funds, equipment, and pricing could have been decisive. “Innovation” is the stated pitch, not a proven cause.

    • The comparison isn’t controlled. Taco Bell is more than three times KFC’s size, KFC is under pressure from rivals, Taco Bell had a summer traffic dip tied to a lettuce-linked cyclospora outbreak, and the Taco Bell renewal appears to have been signed before the KFC announcement.

    • The key claims are company-reported. The $1 billion figure and the narrative about co-development come from the companies’ own statements.

    • Defaults aren’t irrational. Switching costs for KFC, including equipment, training, and supply, are real, and it chose to bear them. That is evidence the alternative looked worth the cost.

    • Asset specificity cuts both ways. Taco Bell’s dependence on Baja Blast also exposes it to PepsiCo’s weakness. A co-created asset can become a hostage.

    • The story is still moving. Yum! Brands reports third-quarter results on November 3, which could change the picture of both chains.

    Which of your longest-running relationships with a customer, supplier, or partner exists because of what you’ve built together, and which exists because nobody has given them a reason to leave?